Unbiased Pinehurst Coins Review: Are They the Top Choice for Collectors?

If you’re contemplating a purchase from Pinehurst Coins, this Pinehurst Coins review is crucial reading. Find out if they stand up to scrutiny on product authenticity, variety, and customer satisfaction—vital factors for any discerning collector or investor in coins and precious metals.

Key Takeaways

Pinehurst Coins: An Overview

Pinehurst Coins logo on a signboard

Born out of a passion for numismatics, Pinehurst Coins, nestled in North Carolina, began its journey in 2004 as an eBay store selling coins. Vincent Wade, a numismatic enthusiast, is the driving force behind this venture. He brings eight years of experience as a combat engineer in the United States Army to the table. His unique perspective and passion brought a new dimension to the coin business.

Pinehurst Coins offers a diverse selection of products for collectors and buyers, including:

As one of the nation’s largest distributors of modern certified coins, Pinehurst Coins has positioned itself as a leading precious metals broker, offering a great coin selection catering to both new collectors and seasoned investors, including the occasional nice coin. With a strong partnership with the United States Mint, Pinehurst Coins ensures the highest quality and authenticity of its products.

Not limited to the online sphere, Pinehurst Coins invites collectors to its retail location in Pinehurst, North Carolina. Open Monday through Friday, it offers a space for clients to have a hands-on experience and interact with the knowledgeable staff.

Product Offerings at Pinehurst Coins

Assortment of silver and gold coins

Pinehurst Coins prides itself on offering a veritable treasure trove of precious metal products. Be it gold, platinum, palladium coins, or silver, they’ve got it all in the form of coins and bars. For those who like a little variety, Pinehurst Coins offers distinct coin categories including Legendary Warriors, Silver American Eagles, and Gold Eagles. They also offer high relief silver antiqued, gold gilded coins, and various silver rounds with unique designs, including silver eagles.

Quality, not just quantity, is upheld at Pinehurst Coins. Every item at Pinehurst Coins goes through rigorous authentication and quality control processes to ensure its integrity and match with the product descriptions.

Beyond coins and rounds, Pinehurst Coins caters to other collector and investor needs. They specialize in the purchase and sale of scrap gold, silver, platinum, and other forms of bullion at Pinehurst Coin Exchange. You can even find rare sports cards and memorabilia in their collection.

Pricing Strategy and Fee Structure

Pinehurst Coins operates an efficient two-way market, with frequently updated buy prices. Please note, these buy prices are subject to change and may not reflect the displayed price. The buy prices are based on a minimum transaction value of $10,000. For smaller transactions, the prices are determined at the discretion of Pinehurst Coins traders.

One of the unique features of Pinehurst Coins is their 10-minute window for checkout. This means that once you’ve added items to your cart, you have 10 minutes to complete the checkout process before prices are readjusted to reflect market changes.

Pinehurst Coins also offers a Price Match Guarantee to ensure competitive prices. If you find a lower price elsewhere, you can request a price match via email or phone.

When compared to other dealers, Pinehurst Coin Exchange offers great prices, which are considered fair and competitive.

Customer Service and Support

Pinehurst Coins is renowned for its swift customer service and efficient resolution of issues. Whether it’s a shipping complication or a product concern, Pinehurst Coins assures customers that most issues are resolved promptly to their satisfaction. Detailed order confirmations are provided through email communication.

The company also offers free in-store appraisals by professional staff. This underpins Pinehurst Coins’ dedication to customer education and service, encouraging collectors to make informed decisions about their investments.

Shipping and Handling

Pinehurst Coins excels in shipping services. They offer:

‘Presale’ items are usually shipped by Pinehurst Coins within 5 business days from the date of order. Shipping dates are stated in product descriptions and can include an additional 5 business days due to external factors.

The meticulous packaging of Pinehurst Coins contributes to repeat patronage. Orders over $750 require signature confirmation upon delivery, offering an additional layer of security. Pinehurst Coins also tries to combine multiple orders into one shipment whenever possible, streamlining the process.

Returns, Exchanges, and Cancellations

For customers looking to cancel an order, they must speak with a customer service representative by phone for pre-approval during Monday to Friday, 10am-5pm. If an order has been picked and is then cancelled, a $35 cancellation fee along with any market loss will be charged.

For returns or exchanges, customers must:

Client Experience with Pinehurst Coins

While a business can promote itself, customer feedback provides a more genuine perspective. Well, Pinehurst Coins boasts an ‘Excellent’ rating of 4.9 out of 5 on Trustpilot and is accredited by the Better Business Bureau. A whopping 95% of their reviews on Trustpilot are 5-star, demonstrating a high level of customer satisfaction and leaving little room for negative reviews.

Customers commend Pinehurst Coins for their great customer service, which includes:

These factors have earned Pinehurst Coins repeat business from many customers.

First-time buyers have noted great experiences with Pinehurst Coins, and long-term customers, some with approximately 5 years of purchasing history, have reported consistently positive experiences. Exceptional customer service has been frequently mentioned in testimonials, with specific praise for Pinehurst’s quick problem resolution, including promptly sending replacements when issues occur.

Comparing Pinehurst Coins to Competitors

While many businesses deal in coins and precious metals, Pinehurst Coins stands out with its wide range of products. In addition to coins, they offer:

Pinehurst Coins also sets itself apart with its commitment to honoring their deals. This has been noted by customers who have had negative experiences with competitors reneging on agreements for new releases.

Investing in Precious Metals and Collectibles

Diversifying investment portfolio with precious metals

The appeal of investing in precious metals and rare coins goes beyond the excitement of collecting. It’s a strategy to diversify an investment portfolio and offer tax advantages, making them particularly beneficial during uncertain economic times. They provide protection of purchasing power and the possibility of an increase in value.

Nonetheless, coin investment, including error coins, demands careful considerations. The market value of coins can experience fluctuations due to public sentiment and the reputation of individual coins, which investors should consider when building their portfolio.

Rare coins, including gold coins, are subject to favorable sales tax treatment, and they can increase in value without incurring annual taxes. This can make them a valuable investment option for some individuals. On the other hand, gold bars and silver are subject to a capital gains tax rate of 15% in the U.S.

Online Security and Privacy

Online security and privacy take precedence in the digital age. Pinehurst Coins adheres to data protection regulations including GDPR, demonstrating their commitment to user privacy and lawful processing of personal information. To ensure transactional security, the website uses HTTPS and TLS 1.2 encryption and does not directly store sensitive payment information.

Users also play a pivotal role in this regard. They are responsible for the confidentiality of their account passwords and must maintain accurate personal information as part of managing their accounts. Pinehurst Coins employs various web technologies such as cookies, web beacons, and Google Analytics to enhance user experience, which are customizable based on user privacy preferences.


Wrapping things up, Pinehurst Coins has shown itself to be a trusted partner for coin enthusiasts and investors alike. With a wide variety of high-quality products, competitive pricing, efficient customer service, and a strong commitment to customer satisfaction, it’s no wonder they’ve earned such high praise from their customers. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or just starting out, Pinehurst Coins offers a treasure trove of opportunities to enrich your collection and investment portfolio.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Pinehurst coins a reputable company?

Yes, Pinehurst Coins is a reputable company with accreditation from the Better Business Bureau and memberships in several respected organizations. You can trust their expertise in numismatics.

Who owns Pinehurst coins?

Vincent Wade is the owner of Pinehurst Coins.

What products does Pinehurst Coins offer?

Pinehurst Coins offers a variety of products, including coins in gold, platinum, palladium, and silver, as well as jewelry, watches, books, collectible supplies, sports cards, and memorabilia. Check them out if you’re interested!

What is the pricing strategy of Pinehurst Coins?

Pinehurst Coins has an efficient two-way market with updated buy prices and a Price Match Guarantee for competitive pricing.

How does Pinehurst Coins handle shipping?

Pinehurst Coins offers free shipping on all orders within the U.S. with most orders shipping out within one business day. You can expect your delivery within five business days.