An Honest Golden Eagle Coins Review: Pros, Cons, and Customer Experiences

Looking for a straightforward golden eagle coins review that cuts through the noise? Here, we provide an unbiased look at their pricing, selection, and customer service to help you make an informed decision. This review will cover both the shine and the tarnish of Golden Eagle Coins’ reputation, backed by actual customer experiences, so you can gauge if they’re the right dealer for your precious metal needs.

Key Takeaways

Golden Eagle Coins: Company Overview

Assortment of golden eagle coins and silver bullion

Established in 1974, Golden Eagle Coins has built a reputation as a reliable online and brick-and-mortar gold and silver bullion dealer. They offer a diverse selection of precious metals products, including gold, silver, platinum, and palladium coins, bars, and rounds. Among their offerings, silver bars are a popular choice for investors and collectors. Their comprehensive assortment of numismatic coins from various countries and mints globally is a testament to their commitment to customer satisfaction.

Pros of Buying from Golden Eagle Coins

Positive customer reviews and ratings

Golden Eagle Coins is more than just an online store for precious metals. It’s a platform that offers competitive pricing, a vast product selection, and a robust reputation in the industry.

But how do these factors impact you as a customer? Let’s dissect these elements.

Competitive Pricing

When it comes to great prices, Golden Eagle Coins has a clear edge. The company offers cash discounted prices for certain payment methods and has separate pricing structures for Credit Card and Paypal orders. Additionally, orders over $99 enjoy free shipping, a significant saving for customers.

However, bear in mind that pricing should not be the only factor in your decision-making process. Some customers have expressed a preference for companies with superior customer service, even at a slightly higher price.

Large Selection

Golden Eagle Coins boasts a wide array of products, including:

For currency enthusiasts, Golden Eagle Coins offers sought-after series of notes, foreign currency options, and the popular golden eagle coin, as well as silver eagles.


Golden Eagle Coins has a solid reputation in the industry, backed by its long-standing operation since 1974 and an A+ rating with the BBB. Their exceptional service, including factors such as knowledge, dependability, and friendliness, has won them accolades, including the Best Circulating Coin in the America the Beautiful Program.

Cons of Buying from Golden Eagle Coins

Disappointed customer with delayed shipment

Despite its advantages, Golden Eagle Coins has its drawbacks. Some customers have reported shipping delays, issues with customer service, and limitations in payment methods.

Let’s examine these issues in detail.

Shipping Delays

Some customers have experienced shipping delays and long wait times for their orders. These issues have been exacerbated by inadequate communication from the company regarding the delays. However, Golden Eagle Coins has stated that the standard delivery timeframe for shipments is generally within 3-14 business days, depending on the volume and content of the order.

Customer Service Issues

Customer service is an integral part of any business, and it seems Golden Eagle Coins has room for improvement in this area, striving for better customer service. Complaints have ranged from slow and expensive shipping to lack of responsiveness to customer inquiries.

In some instances, customers have reported receiving damaged products, making it a case of buyer beware.

Payment Method Limitations

While Golden Eagle Coins accepts a variety of payment methods, including:

Some customers have reported additional charges when using certain payment methods like PayPal.

Positive Customer Experiences

Despite the cons, many customers have had positive experiences with Golden Eagle Coins. Customers have praised the company for:

Some customers have even reported receiving their order in just 7 days, which is considered record time.

Negative Customer Experiences

On the other side of the coin, some customers have had less than stellar experiences. Their only complaint mainly revolves around shipping delays, poor customer service, including inadequate communication, and limitations on payment methods.

Such experiences shed light on the areas where Golden Eagle Coins could improve its operations.

Comparing Golden Eagle Coins to Other Gold Dealers

Comparison of pricing with other gold dealers

Golden Eagle Coins, like any other company, has its strengths and weaknesses. How does it fare when compared to other gold dealers? We’ll evaluate its performance in terms of pricing, product range, and customer satisfaction.

Pricing Comparison

In terms of pricing, Golden Eagle Coins provides competitive offerings. However, they are not the cheapest in the market, with companies like BGASC and SD Bullion offering slightly lower prices.

Yet, Golden Eagle Coins does provide free shipping on orders over $199, which is a significant saving for customers.

Product Offerings

Golden Eagle Coins sets itself apart from other gold dealers with its diverse product offerings. With over 5,000 unique products, including various types of gold and silver bullion, numismatic coins, and currency, it caters to a wide range of collectors and investors.

Customer Satisfaction

Customer satisfaction is a key metric in evaluating a company’s performance, and Golden Eagle Coins has garnered positive feedback from many of its customers. Despite some complaints, the company’s average rating of 4.8 out of 5.0 demonstrates its commitment to customer satisfaction.

Tips for Purchasing from Golden Eagle Coins

If you’re contemplating a purchase from Golden Eagle Coins, here are a few pointers to remember. These include researching the products, reading reviews, and understanding the shipping policies.

Research Products

Before making a purchase, take the time to research the products. Understand the different types of coins, their purity, weight, and the current market value. Golden Eagle Coins provides comprehensive information about their products, including the grading process, which rates coins on a scale from 1 to 70.

Read Reviews

Reading customer reviews can provide insights into the dealer’s reputation and customer experiences. You can find dependable reviews for Golden Eagle Coins on Trustpilot and the Better Business Bureau (BBB) website, as well as on review aggregation sites like Shopper Approved.

Understand Shipping Policies

Before placing an order, familiarize yourself with the company’s shipping policies. Golden Eagle Coins provides free shipping on orders over $199, and understanding the delivery timeframe can help you avoid any surprises or delays.

BBB Accreditation and Trustworthiness

Golden Eagle Coins BBB Accreditation

Golden Eagle Coins:

How to Spot Fake Reviews

In today’s digital age, fake reviews can be a concern. When looking to leave reviews, be cautious of overly positive or negative reviews, a lack of detail, and patterns in reviewer profiles. Checking reviews from reliable sources like Trustpilot and the BBB can also help ensure their authenticity.

Precious Metals Investment Considerations

Investing in precious metals is a significant decision that requires careful consideration of elements like market fluctuations, storage alternatives, and diversification for future purchases.

Let’s explore these factors in more depth on other sites.

Market Fluctuations

The value of precious metals is influenced by market fluctuations. Factors such as:

can all impact the price of gold and other precious metals.

Storage Options

Storing your precious metals safely is crucial. From vault services to home safes, it’s vital to choose a storage method that provides the security your investment deserves.


Diversification is a critical strategy in any investment portfolio. By spreading your investments across different types of metals, you can balance your portfolio and reduce potential losses.


Golden Eagle Coins has a strong reputation in the industry, with competitive pricing and a large product selection. However, like any business, it has its areas for improvement, such as shipping delays and customer service. It’s always recommended to conduct thorough research, read reviews, and understand the company’s policies before making a purchase. As with any investment, consider market fluctuations, storage options, and the importance of diversification.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Golden Eagle coins a good investment?

Yes, Golden Eagle coins can be a good investment, especially if you pay a reasonable premium above their bullion value. They represent a low-risk, high-return investment, and can be legally purchased in a precious metal IRA.

Is Golden Eagle legit?

Yes, Golden Eagle is legit with a trusted dealer since 1974 and an A+ rating with BBB.

Are Gold American Eagle coins worth anything?

Yes, Gold American Eagle coins are worth a significant amount, typically between $1800-$2100 for a 1 oz coin, as of current market value.

Are Gold Eagle coins pure gold?

Yes, Gold Eagle coins have a purity of 0.9167 and contain exactly 1 troy ounce of pure gold in each coin. They are produced by the U.S. government and minted at the U.S. Mint at West Point.

Does Golden Eagle Coins offer competitive pricing?

Yes, Golden Eagle Coins offers competitive pricing, but some customers prioritize superior customer service over price. Consider your priorities when making a purchase decision.