How to Sell Silver Coins for Melt Value?

When it’s time to sell your silver coins, knowing their melt value is crucial. This straightforward guide explains how to sell silver coins for melt value, honing in on practical advice to determine your coins’ worth, identify credible buyers, and complete the sale without hassle. Expect clear instructions that demystify the process, ensuring you’re equipped to sell your silver coins effectively.

Key Takeaways

Understanding Melt Value

acetylene, aluminium, aluminum

Silver coins, as well as gold and silver coins, are more than just currency or collectibles. They represent a tangible asset with an inherent value derived from their precious metal content, such as silver bullion. This inherent value, or melt value, is the worth of the silver within the coin. Grasping this concept is fundamental if you have plans to sell your silver coins, as it establishes the foundation of any sale.

However, the melt value of a coin isn’t the only factor to consider when selling. The coin’s condition, rarity, and demand among collectors can also influence its worth. But for coins with little to no collectible value, like common silver coins or junk silver coins, the melt value is often the most relevant indicator of their worth. We will further analyze the concept of melt value and the influencing factors.

What is Melt Value?

In the world of precious metals, the term “melt value” refers to the monetary value of a silver coin if it were melted down and sold purely for its silver content. It’s calculated by multiplying the weight of the silver in the coin by the current market price of silver. This is the value you want to keep in mind when planning to sell your silver coins for their metal content.

For some, selling coins for their melt value may appear odd, particularly those habituated to collecting numismatic coins for their value. However, not all silver coins hold numismatic value. “Junk” silver coins, for example, are typically older coins with high silver content but little to no collector’s value. Their worth lies primarily in their melt value, making them a popular choice for investors and individuals looking to cash in on the value of silver.

Factors Affecting Melt Value

Three key factors influence the melt value of a silver coin: the silver content of the coin, its weight, and the prevailing market price of silver. The silver content refers to the percentage of silver in the coin. Most U.S. silver coins minted before 1965, for example, contain 90% silver. However, there are exceptions. For example, Kennedy half dollars minted from 1965 through 1970 contain only 40% silver. These coins have a lower silver content compared to earlier mintings..

The weight of the coin is another major factor affecting its melt value. It indicates the amount of silver present in the coin, which is then multiplied by the current silver price to determine the melt value. For example, a Morgan or Peace Silver Dollar weighs approximately 26.73 grams and contains around .7734 ounces of silver. By multiplying the weight of the silver by the current silver price, you can calculate the coin’s melt value, especially when dealing with silver dollars.

Assessing Your Silver Coins

money, dollars, coins

Once the concept of melt value is clear, the subsequent stage in selling your silver coins involves their assessment. This involves determining their silver content and evaluating their condition. These two factors play a significant role in determining the worth of your coins and ensuring you get a fair price when selling them.

Determining the silver content of your coins can be as simple as doing a bit of research. The coin’s year, design, and mint mark can often tell you a lot about its composition.

Evaluating the condition of your coin collection, on the other hand, requires a closer look at your collectible coins, including rare coins. Signs of wear and tear such as scratches, stains, or loss of detail can significantly lower a coin’s value.

We will elaborate on these steps further.

Determining Silver Content

The initial stage in assessing your silver coins involves:

One way to determine the silver content of your coins is by researching their composition. Many coins have their composition and the year they were minted listed online. For example, most U.S. coins minted before 1965 contain 90% silver, while Kennedy half-dollars minted from 1965 to 1970 contain only 40% silver. By doing a little research, you can find out the silver content of your coins and use this information to calculate their melt value.

Evaluating Coin Condition

Another significant element to contemplate when selling is the condition of your coins. Coins in good condition can command higher prices than those that are worn or damaged. When examining your coins, look for signs of wear such as scratches, stains, or loss of detail. These can significantly lower a coin’s value.

If you’re unsure about the condition of your coins, consider having them graded by a professional coin grading service. These services assess the condition of coins based on factors such as preservation, luster, and coloration. Having your coins professionally graded can give you a clearer idea of their value and help you negotiate a better price when selling.

Calculating Melt Value

silver coins, edge, embossing

Following the identification of the silver content and the evaluation of your coins’ condition, the next step involves the calculation of their melt value. This involves finding the current silver prices and performing some simple calculations. The melt value of a coin is determined by multiplying the weight and silver content of the coin by the current market price of silver.

However, it’s important to remember that the melt value is just one factor when selling your coins. Other factors, such as the coin’s condition and rarity, can also influence its value. But for coins with little to no numismatic value, the melt value is the most important factor to consider. We will further analyze how to find current silver prices and perform melt value calculations.

Finding Current Silver Prices

The current market price of silver is a key factor in calculating the melt value of your coins. This price, also known as the “spot price,” fluctuates throughout the day based on market conditions. You can find the current spot price of silver on financial news websites or by contacting a reputable precious metal dealer.

Keep in mind that the spot price of silver is typically quoted per troy ounce. If your coins are weighed in grams or other units, you’ll need to convert these weights to troy ounces before calculating the melt value. There are plenty of online calculators and conversion tools available to help you do this.

Performing Melt Value Calculations

Once you have the current silver price and the weight and silver content of your coins, you can calculate their melt value. The formula for calculating the melt value is simple: multiply the weight of the silver in the coin (in troy ounces) by the current spot price of silver.

For example, let’s say you have a Morgan Silver Dollar which contains 0.7734 troy ounces of silver. If the current spot price of silver is $24.43 per troy ounce, the silver value, or melt value, of the coin would be $18.895 (0.7734 x $24.43 = $18.895). Keep in mind that this is the minimum value you should expect when selling your coin for its silver content.

Identifying Potential Buyers

coins, calculator, budget

Having assessed your coins and calculated their melt value, the subsequent step involves identifying potential buyers. There are many places where you can sell your silver coins, including local coin dealers, online marketplaces, and precious metal refiners. Each of these options has its pros and cons, so it’s important to choose the one that best suits your needs.

There are several options for selling your coins, each with its own advantages and considerations:

  1. Local coin dealers and shops: These offer a convenient way to sell your coins, but they may not always offer the best prices.

  2. Online marketplaces: These reach a wider audience, but they can involve fees and shipping costs.

  3. Precious metal refiners: These typically buy silver coins for their melt value and can offer competitive prices, especially for larger quantities or lower-grade coins.

We will offer a more detailed analysis of these options.

Local Coin Dealers and Shops

Selling your silver coins to a local coin dealer or shop can be a convenient and straightforward option to sell silver coins. These establishments specialize in buying and selling coins and can often provide immediate cash payment. However, it’s important to choose a reputable and experienced dealer to ensure you get a fair price for your coins.

When visiting a local dealer, follow these steps:

  1. Bring your coins and any information you have about their silver content and condition.

  2. Be prepared to negotiate if the dealer’s offer is lower than the melt value of your coins.

  3. If you’re not satisfied with the offer, don’t be afraid to walk away and try another dealer.

  4. Remember, it’s always a good idea to get multiple quotes before making a decision.

Online Marketplaces and Auctions

Online platforms like eBay provide a wider audience for your silver coins and can potentially fetch a higher price. However, selling online involves additional considerations such as listing fees, shipping costs, and payment processing fees. It’s important to factor these costs into your selling price to ensure you still make a profit.

If you decide to sell on an online marketplace, make sure to:

Precious Metal Refiners

Precious metal refiners buy silver coins, including silver bullion coins, primarily for their melt value, making them a viable option if your coins have little to no numismatic value. Refiners often offer competitive prices, especially for larger quantities or lower-grade coins. They also typically pay in cash, which can be a plus if you need funds immediately.

However, selling to a refiner often involves shipping your coins, which can carry risks and costs. Some refiners cover shipping costs and provide insurance, but not all do. It’s essential to read the fine print and understand the terms before sending your coins. Also, as with any buyer, it’s crucial to research the refiner’s reputation to ensure they’re trustworthy and reliable.

Negotiating and Selling Your Silver Coins

Having identified potential buyers and received offers, the concluding step involves the negotiation and sale of your silver coins. This can be a delicate dance, as you want to maximize your return without driving away potential buyers. Remember, knowledge is power in negotiations, so being well-informed about your coins’ value and the current silver market can give you an edge.

Don’t be afraid to counteroffer if a buyer’s initial offer is lower than your coins’ melt value. However, also be willing to compromise and consider offers slightly below melt value, especially if the buyer is reputable and offers a smooth and convenient selling process. We will consider some strategies for comparing offers and conducting negotiations.

Comparing Offers

Comparing offers from multiple buyers can help ensure you get the best price for your silver coins. Don’t just accept the first offer you receive. Instead, get quotes from several buyers, including local dealers, online marketplaces, and refiners.

When comparing offers, consider not only the price but also the convenience and safety of the transaction. For example, a local dealer might offer a lower price but provide immediate cash payment and eliminate the risk and cost of shipping. An online buyer might offer a higher price but require you to ship the coins and wait for payment.

Tips for Negotiating

Negotiating can be a bit of an art, but there are some strategies that can help you succeed. First, be well-informed about your coins’ melt value and the current silver market. This will give you a solid basis for your negotiations and help you recognize fair offers.

Second, be prepared to walk away if a buyer’s offer is too low. This can show buyers that you’re not desperate to sell and have other options.

Finally, don’t be afraid to counteroffer. Even if a buyer’s initial offer is low, they might be willing to negotiate up to a more reasonable price.

Storing and Protecting Your Silver Coins

portugal, lisbon, money

While you are gearing up to sell your silver coins, proper storage and protection are important. Proper storage can prevent damage that could reduce your coins’ value. It can also protect your coins from theft.

Whether you’re storing your coins in a home safe, a safe deposit box, or a secure storage facility, make sure they’re in a location that’s not only secure but also free from extreme temperatures and humidity. Additionally, handle your coins carefully to avoid causing scratches or other damage.

Selecting a Storage Location

Opting for a secure storage location for your silver coins is paramount to safeguard their value. If you’re storing your coins at home, consider investing in a good-quality safe. Make sure it’s well-hidden and securely anchored to prevent theft.

If you’re storing a large quantity of coins or don’t feel secure storing them at home, consider a safe deposit box at a bank or a secure storage facility. These options provide high levels of security, but they can also carry costs and may not be as convenient as home storage.

Handling and Caring for Silver Coins

Handling and caring for your silver coins properly can help maintain their condition and value. When handling your coins, use cotton gloves or a soft cloth to prevent fingerprints and scratches. Avoid cleaning your coins with harsh chemicals or abrasive materials, as these can cause damage.

When storing your coins, place them in individual plastic sleeves or tubes to protect them from scratches and other damage. Avoid storing them in areas with high humidity or extreme temperatures, as these conditions can cause tarnish or corrosion.


Selling silver coins for their melt value can be a rewarding experience if you’re well-prepared. By understanding the concept of melt value, assessing your coins, calculating their melt value, and identifying potential buyers, you can ensure you get the best return on your investment. Remember to compare offers from different buyers and negotiate effectively to maximize your return. And don’t forget to store and protect your coins properly to maintain their value.

Whether you’re selling a few common silver coins or a large collection of rare coins, being well-informed and prepared can make the process smoother and more profitable. So why not start assessing your silver coins and see what they’re worth? You might be surprised at how much you can earn from your coin collection.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it better to sell silver coins for melt?

Selling silver coins for melt value may not get you the best price, but you can find potential buyers through online auction sites, pawn shops, local silver dealers, and even some coin collectors. It’s also possible to sell directly to reputable silver refineries.

What is the best way to sell my silver coins?

The best way to sell your silver coins depends on their value. If they are collectible, consider selling them through an online auction house, on ebay, or to a reputable coin dealer. For non-collectible coins, selling to a local smelter or scrap dealer might be the best option. Keep track of silver’s market price as it fluctuates.

Can you legally melt down silver coins?

Yes, it is legal to melt down silver coins in the US, as there are no silver coins in circulation and melting them would have no effect on day-to-day transactions.

What is the melt value of a silver coin?

The melt value of a silver coin is determined by its silver content and the current market price of silver.

How should I store and protect my silver coins?

To store and protect your silver coins, place them in a secure location like a home safe or a safe deposit box. Handle them with care to prevent scratches and avoid using harsh chemicals or abrasive materials for cleaning.