Goldco vs Provident Metals: Ultimate Showdown

The journey of investing in precious metals begins with choosing the right company. Two such companies that have established themselves as industry leaders are Goldco and Provident Metals. Both offer a plethora of precious metals products and services, but how do they stack up against each other in the “goldco vs provident metals” comparison? Let’s find out.

Key Takeaways

Goldco and Provident Metals: Company Overviews


Goldco and Provident Metals hold esteemed positions in the precious metals industry, extending a wide array of products and services to investors. Goldco, one of the leading gold IRA companies, was established with the objective of offering investors a dependable means of safeguarding their wealth through precious metals. Provident Metals, on the other hand, was founded in 2009 by Joe Merrick, and has received positive feedback from customers, as evidenced by its 4.5-star rating on Trustpilot and an A- rating from the Better Business Bureau.

Both companies have their fundamental principles rooted in transparency, integrity, and customer satisfaction. Their mission revolves around offering secure and trustworthy investment avenues for individuals looking to diversify their retirement savings with precious metals, while emphasizing superior customer service and robust ethical principles.


Goldco, established in 2006, specializes in offering a comprehensive range of silver and gold bullion products, including IRA-approved precious metals, to help investors safeguard their wealth. The company is privately held and located in the Los Angeles area, with a track record of over ten years in serving customers who are interested in purchasing precious metals to protect their retirement savings.

The company, American Hartford Gold, is committed to helping Americans enhance their financial security by offering wealth-protecting solutions in the precious metals market. Goldco places a strong emphasis on customer service and education, offering a range of resources to help investors make informed decisions.

Provident Metals

As a well-regarded online merchant, Provident Metals is recognized for providing a wide range of precious metal items such as:

Investors have the opportunity to benefit from excellent service, competitive prices, and a varied selection of products.

Provident Metals offers several notable and unique product ranges for bullion investments, including:

Comparing Goldco and Provident Metals


When it comes to product offerings, Goldco and Provident Metals both provide a selection of precious metals, encompassing:

However, Goldco offers a more comprehensive range across all these metals, whereas Provident Metals focuses more on gold, silver, and platinum bullion products.

In terms of fees, Goldco imposes a one-time IRA setup fee of $50, a wire fee of $30, and an annual maintenance fee of $80. On the other hand, Provident Metals has a more straightforward pricing model, with the cost displayed on the website representing the cost of the metals and no additional undisclosed costs.

Both companies have strong customer service reputations, but Goldco has a slight edge in terms of customer satisfaction and responsiveness. Goldco has achieved a 5-star rating on Trustpilot and holds an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau. However, some customers have expressed grievances regarding Goldco’s insufficient disclosure of transaction details and the occurrence of unsolicited calls.

Product Offerings

Goldco and Provident Metals both provide a selection of precious metals, including gold, silver, platinum, palladium, and other precious metals.

Goldco offers a comprehensive range across all these metals, whereas Provident Metals specializes in gold, silver, and platinum bullion products.

Indeed, both Goldco and Provident Metals provide IRA-approved precious metal products. Goldco specializes in offering a range of gold, silver, platinum, and palladium that are eligible for inclusion in IRAs, while Provident Metals provides a diverse selection of IRA-eligible products, including the aforementioned metals as well as other bullion options.

Fees and Costs

Goldco’s fee structure includes:

Nevertheless, Goldco maintains transparency by not having any hidden fees or charges for its customers.

At Provident Metals, the cost displayed on the website represents the cost of the metals. Any fees associated with precious metals IRAs are imposed by the trust and provider company, with no additional undisclosed costs.

Customer Service and Reputation

Goldco has achieved the following accolades:

However, typical grievances expressed by customers regarding Goldco include the insufficient disclosure of transaction details and the occurrence of unsolicited calls, which the company has since discontinued.

Precious Metal IRA Services


A precious metal IRA is a type of individual retirement account that encompasses valuable metals like gold, silver, and palladium, in lieu of traditional assets such as stocks or bonds. Specifically, a Gold IRA is a subtype of precious metal IRA where the predominant asset is physical gold.

To be eligible for an IRA, precious metals are required to adhere to specific regulatory criteria, which includes meeting minimum purity standards. For instance, platinum and palladium products must have a minimum purity of 99.95%.

Precious metal IRA services are offered by both Goldco and Provident Metals. Goldco offers extensive IRA services, which encompass account setup, rollovers, and ongoing management, prioritizing customer support and education. Provident Metals, on the other hand, partners with Preferred Trust Company for IRA administration but lacks the same level of experience and expertise as Goldco.

Goldco’s IRA Services

The procedure for establishing an IRA with Goldco includes signing an agreement, completing the necessary documents, and submitting them to Goldco, who will then manage the remaining process. Goldco offers IRA-eligible gold coins and provides information about rollovers and transfers to ensure that clients have access to appropriate custodial choices for their IRA assets.

Additionally, Goldco provides comprehensive customer support for IRA accounts, including:

Provident Metals’ IRA Services

Provident Metals offers the opportunity for investors to securely store precious metals in a traditional or Roth IRA. To initiate a precious metals IRA, individuals are required to:

  1. Open an account with one of their custodian partners, such as Sterling Trust Company or American Estate & Trust Company.

  2. Deposit funds into the account.

  3. Engage with Provident Metals to acquire IRA-approved precious metal products.

Provident Metals provides a variety of IRA products, including a tax-free Roth IRA. The contribution limits are $6,000 for individuals 49 and below and $7,000 for those above 50, depending on the investor’s age.

Security and Storage Options


Goldco prioritizes the security of its storage solutions, employing extensive security monitoring measures like:

Additionally, the company has implemented stringent internal controls to mitigate the potential for internal security breaches. Goldco guarantees the safety and security of the precious metals in their storage by partnering with highly secure bullion depositories and implementing an extensive security system. This system includes motion detectors, sound detectors, vibration detectors, and metal detectors, complemented by strict internal controls.

Indeed, both Goldco and Provident Metals have implemented insurance policies for their storage facilities, offering an extra level of safeguard for the precious metals held by investors.

Goldco’s Storage Solutions

Goldco provides storage options through collaborations with esteemed depositories such as the Delaware Depository and other secure facilities, offering a variety of choices for the secure storage of gold and silver coins, including catering to gold IRA storage requirements.

The price for Goldco’s storage solutions is $100 per year, encompassing an annual maintenance fee, rendering it a competitive choice for secure precious metals storage.

Provident Metals’ Storage Solutions

Provident Metals provides a range of storage options including:

Indeed, Provident Metals does provide segregated storage options for precious metals, thereby guaranteeing individual allocation and security for investors’ assets.

Educational Resources and Support


Goldco offers a multitude of educational resources, including:

On the other hand, Provident Metals provides investors with:

For those considering this option, a provident metals review can offer valuable insights into the company’s offerings and customer satisfaction.

While both companies provide resources and support, their methods differ. Goldco provides:

to help investors make informed decisions. Provident Metals, however, offers some educational resources, but they are less comprehensive and focused compared to Goldco’s offerings.

Goldco’s Educational Resources

Goldco, in partnership with Birch Gold Group, provides a wide range of educational resources that encompass various subjects such as:

Their materials, provided by Augusta Precious Metals, are renowned for their excellence and are tailored to empower investors with the information needed to make prudent choices regarding their precious metals investments.

Indeed, Goldco provides personalized consultations aimed at offering guidance on Gold IRA investing and assisting clients in comprehending their investment options. Skilled account representatives deliver tailored advice and support during these complimentary sessions, enabling clients to make well-informed investing choices.

Provident Metals’ Educational Resources

Provident Metals offers a wide range of educational resources that encompass various aspects of investing in precious metals. These resources cover topics such as:

Provident Metals offers their educational resources in the form of online articles and resources accessible on their website. These resources cover a range of topics including the history of money, steps to initiate precious metals investment, and the production processes of mints for bullion. Additionally, they provide a beginner’s guide to investment.

Diversification Opportunities

Diversification in precious metals investing is crucial, as it aids in lowering the overall risk of the asset portfolio. Both Goldco and Provident Metals offer opportunities for investors to diversify their portfolios with a range of precious metals products.

Investors in precious metals utilize palladium to enhance diversification within their portfolios. Bars are considered to be the most versatile form of investment in the realm of precious metals. They are available in various weights and sizes, with gold bars starting at as little as one gram and silver bars at a single ounce.

Pros and Cons of Investing with Goldco vs Provident Metals

Investing with Goldco offers several benefits including portfolio diversification, potential price appreciation, inflation protection, and the possibility to own physical gold as bars or coins. However, investing with Goldco presents several disadvantages, including restricted access to funds, inability to store gold at home, limited duration for investment in a gold IRA, and various fees and expenses. Furthermore, Goldco mandates a minimum investment of $25,000.

Investing with Provident Metals provides the following benefits:

However, a primary concern when investing with Provident Metals is the documented instances of inadequate support on their website. This necessitates prudence and suggests that investors should exercise discernment when utilizing this platform.


In conclusion, both Goldco and Provident Metals offer a range of services and products for precious metals investors. While Goldco stands out with its comprehensive IRA services, exceptional customer service, and extensive educational resources, Provident Metals offers a wider range of precious metals and more straightforward pricing. Ultimately, the choice between the two companies depends on your individual investment goals and needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Goldco a reputable company?

Yes, Goldco is a reputable company that offers direct purchase of precious metals, making it a reliable option for investors seeking a safe-haven investment.

What is the most reputable place to buy gold?

You can consider JM Bullion, American Precious Metals Exchange (APMEX), and American Hartford Gold as reputable places to buy gold. These are well-known and trusted gold dealers.

Are provident metals and JM Bullion the same company?

No, Provident Metals Corp. is a wholly owned subsidiary of JM Bullion, Inc. There is no indication that they are the same company.

What is the annual fee for Goldco?

Goldco’s annual fee is roughly $180, which works out to 0.72% of the minimum investment required. This rate is competitive compared to expense ratios of other IRAs and 401(k) plans.

What are the main differences between Goldco and Provident Metals?

The main difference between Goldco and Provident Metals is that Goldco specializes in IRA services and offers comprehensive educational resources, while Provident Metals offers a wider range of precious metals and straightforward pricing. Consider what best fits your investment goals and educational needs when choosing between the two.