Advantage Gold vs Rosland Capital: In-Depth Comparison

In the world of investing, gold Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs) have emerged as a popular choice for those looking to diversify their portfolio and hedge against market volatility. Two companies that have risen to prominence in this arena are Advantage Gold and Rosland Capital. As reputable players in the precious metals industry, both offer a wide range of services to investors. But how do they stack up against each other in the “Advantage Gold vs Rosland Capital” comparison? Let’s dig deep and compare these leading gold IRA companies to help you make an informed decision.

Key Takeaways

Company Overview: Advantage Gold and Rosland Capital

gold, bars, exhibition

Advantage Gold has carved a niche for itself in the precious metals industry with its extensive customer base and favorable reviews. Known for its educational resources, the company empowers its clients with knowledge about precious metals investments, helping them make informed decisions. As a testament to its stellar service, Advantage Gold has garnered recognition in the industry, standing shoulder-to-shoulder with other gold IRA companies, such as Augusta Precious Metals.

Despite a wider spread and a higher volume of BBB and BCA complaints, Rosland Capital has still managed to make a mark in the industry. This could account for its absence from the primary list of top gold IRA companies. However, like Advantage Gold and Birch Gold Group, Rosland Capital also provides educational content, underlining the importance of such resources in guiding an investor’s decision to invest in a gold IRA.

Products and Services Offered

gold, coins, bullions

When comparing gold IRA companies, one of the critical factors to consider is the range of products and services offered. Advantage Gold and Rosland Capital both offer a variety of investment options, including precious metal IRAs and physical gold and silver purchases. Nonetheless, each company has its unique offerings and areas of specialization, creating distinct investment opportunities for investors.

Advantage Gold specializes in facilitating the conversion of eligible accounts into precious metals IRAs. This includes comprehensive management and storage of the metals, ensuring compliance with IRS-approved retirement investment regulations. Meanwhile, Rosland Capital concentrates on gold IRAs, providing comparable services to maintain compliance with IRS regulations.

In terms of physical gold and silver purchases, both companies offer a diverse range of IRS-approved coins and bars. Investors can select from a variety of options, with the flexibility to choose their custodians and storage providers for the physical assets. Keep in mind, the availability of collectibles may vary. Investors are advised to directly contact the companies to inquire about their current offerings.

Precious Metal IRAs

A precious metal IRA is a form of self-directed IRA that enables investors to possess physical precious metals such as:

This type of IRA involves initiating an account with a gold IRA company, which then collaborates with a custodian to oversee the storage and monitoring of the physical metals, in exchange for a fee.

Both Advantage Gold and Rosland Capital offer this service, but with a slight difference in their areas of specialization. While Advantage Gold aids in converting eligible accounts into precious metals IRAs, Rosland Capital’s primary focus is on gold IRAs. Regardless of their specialty, both companies ensure comprehensive management and storage of the metals in compliance with IRS-approved retirement investment regulations.

Physical Gold & Silver Purchases

As part of their service offerings, both Advantage Gold and Rosland Capital provide options for investors to make physical gold and silver purchases. These purchases can be made either within an IRA or for Direct Delivery, offering flexibility to the investor. Additionally, both companies offer comprehensive education and guidance to support their customers.

In terms of the varieties of physical gold and silver available, Rosland Capital provides a range of options including bullion bars, bullion coins, and premium coins. They also offer other precious metals such as silver, platinum, and palladium. On the other hand, Advantage Gold provides information on acquiring gold bars and coins from trusted online vendors, emphasizing essential factors such as authentication verification when procuring physical gold.

Numismatic Coins & Collectibles

Numismatic coins and collectibles typically refer to older coins that hold significant value for collectors. When investing in a gold IRA, it’s essential to understand the options available for numismatic coins and collectibles. Both Advantage Gold and Rosland Capital offer a range of these investment options, but the specific offerings may vary, and it’s advisable to contact each company directly for the most current information.

Advantage Gold provides an extensive selection of gold, silver, and platinum coins suitable for investment, including gold coins approved by the IRS. On the other hand, American Hartford Gold offers a selection of high-quality numismatic gold coins and rare premium silver numismatic coins, featuring a unique assortment of coins depicting Lady Liberty in fine gold and silver.

Fees and Pricing Structure

coins, calculator, budget

A key consideration for any investor when choosing a gold IRA company is the fee structure. Both Advantage Gold and Rosland Capital prioritize fee transparency, which is crucial in fostering trust among clients. However, the specific fees for account setup and maintenance, as well as storage fees, vary between the two companies. In addition to these, the companies’ buyback policies and fees can significantly impact investors’ returns, making it essential for investors to understand these before investing.

Rosland Capital provides clear disclosure of fees on their website, with a minimum purchase requirement of $5,000. The fee structure for account setup and maintenance at Advantage Gold is not specified in the available data, but both companies appear to emphasize fee transparency.

It’s also worth noting that both companies charge mandatory storage fees for gold IRAs, although the exact fees are not disclosed in the available data.

Account Setup & Maintenance Fees

When setting up a gold IRA account, both Advantage Gold and Rosland Capital charge initial setup fees. Advantage Gold’s setup fee varies between $50 and $150, while Rosland Capital charges a flat fee of $50 for the initial setup of a gold IRA account. This setup fee is a one-time charge levied at the beginning of the investment process.

In addition to the initial setup fee, both companies also charge annual maintenance fees for their precious metals IRA accounts. Advantage Gold’s annual maintenance fee can range from $150 to $250. Investors should take these fees into account as they add to the total cost of the investment.

Storage Fees

Gold IRAs require the physical metals to be stored in a secure location. This storage is typically overseen by a custodian and involves certain fees. Segregated storage, a specialized storage arrangement where an investor’s assets are kept separate from others, typically entails specific storage fees. Grasping these fees is critical, as they can considerably influence the overall expenses tied to investing in a gold IRA.

Both Advantage Gold and Rosland Capital offer segregated storage options for their clients. Advantage Gold charges a storage fee of $150 per year for segregated storage. On the other hand, Rosland Capital’s segregated storage fees range from $100 to $150 per year.

In addition to segregated storage, both companies also offer non-segregated storage options, providing flexibility to investors.

Buyback Policies & Fees

Another crucial aspect to consider when choosing a gold IRA company is its buyback policy. Both Advantage Gold and Rosland Capital offer buyback programs, which enhance the liquidity of your investment through the liquidation of your metals. These buyback programs are typically conducted at wholesale price, which is approximately one-third cheaper than the retail price,.

It’s important to note that the ‘spread’ imposed by gold IRA companies can significantly impact investors’ returns. This spread can lead to a decrease of up to 30% compared to the gold’s market price, representing one of the hidden fees investors must be mindful of. Advantage Gold does not impose any fees for their buyback program, providing added value to investors.

Customer Service & Support

review, opinion, feedback

Customer service and support are crucial elements to consider when choosing a gold IRA company. Prioritizing excellent customer service, both Advantage Gold and Rosland Capital offer comprehensive educational resources, impressive client satisfaction ratings, and maintain a high level of responsiveness and availability. However, the specifics of their customer service offerings differ, providing unique experiences for their customers.

Goldco, one of the best gold ira companies, sets a high bar in terms of customer service, making it a strong contender for the title of best gold ira company. The company provides complimentary storage for five years, support for gold IRA rollovers, and no annual fees or transfer charges, reflecting their commitment to superior customer service. This emphasis on customer service is also apparent in Advantage Gold and Rosland Capital, despite differences in their specific offerings.

Responsiveness & Availability

When it comes to responsiveness and availability, the operating hours of a company’s customer service can play a crucial role. The operating hours dictate when customers can expect to receive support and assistance, enhancing the overall customer experience.

Although the operating hours of Advantage Gold’s customer service are not publicly disclosed, the company can be reached at (888) 501-9001 for feedback or questions. This indicates their commitment to being accessible and responsive to their customers, ensuring they receive timely assistance and support.

Educational Resources

Educational resources can significantly contribute to an investor’s decision-making process. Both Advantage Gold and Rosland Capital offer a range of educational resources that help investors understand the complexities of the precious metals market and make well-informed investment decisions.

Advantage Gold provides educational resources that include materials aimed at educating clients about the precious metals market. On the other hand, Rosland Capital offers a wealth of information on its website, including details about gold IRAs, the pre-purchase process of precious metals, and guidance on gold spot prices and common mistakes made by first-time buyers.

Client Satisfaction Ratings

Client satisfaction ratings can provide valuable insights into a company’s performance and the quality of its services. With commendable client satisfaction ratings, both Advantage Gold and Rosland Capital demonstrate their commitment to ensuring customer satisfaction. Advantage Gold has an average rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars based on customer reviews on TrustLink, solidifying its esteemed five-star reputation. On the other hand, Rosland Capital has been awarded an A+ rating by the Better Business Bureau, indicating a high level of customer satisfaction. However, both companies also face some dissatisfaction among clients, mainly due to customer service and product quality concerns.

Storage Options & Partnerships

portugal, lisbon, money

Storage options and partnerships play a crucial role in the operation of gold IRAs. Both Advantage Gold and Rosland Capital offer a variety of storage options, including domestic and international facilities. They also maintain relationships with custodians who handle the administrative functions mandated by the IRS for gold IRAs,.

For domestic storage, Advantage Gold relies on the Delaware Depository and partners with STRATA Trust Company as their recommended custodian. Meanwhile, Rosland Capital provides IRS-approved storage facilities and collaborates with Equity Institutional as the custodian for their Gold IRA accounts. The storage facilities used by both companies are secure and adhere to the required standards, providing peace of mind for investors,.

Domestic Storage Facilities

For domestic storage, Advantage Gold utilizes the Delaware Depository, with Brinks Global Services USA ensuring the security of the physical gold. The storage facilities are safeguarded by:

On the other hand, Rosland Capital provides:

Both companies provide an added layer of protection through insurance policies, ensuring financial protection against theft, vandalism, and weather damages,.

International Storage Options

In terms of international storage options, Advantage Gold provides services through the Delaware Depository, with Brinks Global Services USA ensuring the security of the physical gold. They have established a partnership with Brinks Global Services USA, known for its secure storage solutions, to offer international clients a safe storage option for their physical gold,.

Meanwhile, Rosland Capital offers home storage as an international storage option for their clients. While this offers convenience, it’s important for investors to consider the security implications of storing valuable precious metals at home. As with domestic storage, both companies ensure a high level of security for their international storage facilities, providing peace of mind for investors,.

Custodian Relationships

The role of a custodian in precious metal IRAs involves:

Advantage Gold collaborates with STRATA Trust Company as their recommended custodian, whereas Rosland Capital collaborates with Equity Institutional for their Gold IRA accounts. By working with reputable custodians, both companies ensure that the IRS regulations for gold IRAs are strictly adhered to, providing investors with the assurance and protection they need.

Reputation & Industry Accreditations

Reputation and industry accreditations serve as important indicators of a company’s credibility and performance in the industry. Both Advantage Gold and Rosland Capital hold notable accolades, reflecting their commitment to excellence and adherence to industry standards.

In recognition of their exceptional customer support, Advantage Gold received the ‘Best of TrustLink’ award. Moreover, even though it’s not as established as some other firms in the industry, Advantage Gold is regarded as reputable and anticipated to sustain its operations for at least another decade. This is largely attributed to the company’s commitment to customer satisfaction and the provision of exceptional services, earning it a high rating.

Pros & Cons of Investing with Advantage Gold vs Rosland Capital

While investing in a gold IRA can present numerous benefits, potential drawbacks also exist. Both Advantage Gold and Rosland Capital offer several advantages to investors, such as portfolio diversification and protection against inflation. Yet, they also carry potential disadvantages that investors should weigh before deciding.

Potential drawbacks of investing with Advantage Gold include the volatility of precious metal prices, absence of income stream, and factors to consider regarding storage and security for physical assets. On the other hand, investing with Rosland Capital can present significant challenges given the speculative nature and risks associated with investing in precious metals and rare coins. These include wider spreads on prices, numerous BBB complaints, and concerns related to storage security, transparency of fees, and sales tactics.

Advantage Gold Pros & Cons

Advantage Gold offers many benefits to investors, including:

The company’s educational resources and customer support are also well-reputed, providing investors with valuable knowledge and assistance.

Nonetheless, investing with Advantage Gold carries certain drawbacks, including:

Rosland Capital Pros & Cons

Investing with Rosland Capital offers several advantages:

These advantages make investing with Rosland Capital a smart choice.

Nonetheless, investing with Rosland Capital can pose significant drawbacks due to the speculative nature and risks tied to investing in precious metals and rare coins. These include:

Thus, it’s crucial for investors to thoroughly research and exercise caution before investing with Rosland Capital.

Case Studies: Success Stories from Clients

Success stories shared by clients of Advantage Gold and Rosland Capital highlight their positive experiences. These testimonials provide real-world insights into the services offered by these companies and how they have helped clients achieve their investment goals.

Advantage Gold’s clients have highlighted the company’s comprehensive guidance and valuable recommendations, contributing to its high rating from the Better Business Bureau and a 4.83 out of 5-star customer rating. On the other hand, Rosland Capital’s clients have praised the company for its transparent pricing, clear breakdown of costs, and robust customer support, leading to a 4-star rating on Trustpilot and an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau.


In conclusion, both Advantage Gold and Rosland Capital offer a range of services to investors looking to invest in gold IRAs. They provide various investment options, including precious metal IRAs, physical gold and silver purchases, and numismatic coins and collectibles. While both companies prioritize fee transparency and customer service, their specific offerings and fee structures differ. Therefore, it’s essential for investors to carefully consider their individual needs and preferences when choosing a gold IRA company.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Advantage Gold legit?

Yes, Advantage Gold is a legit company with a commendable reputation in the gold IRA industry, holding an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau and receiving high customer review scores.

What is the number one gold investment company?

The number one gold investment company is Augusta Precious Metals, according to experts.

What is the best gold investment to buy?

The best gold investment to buy is mutual funds and ETFs, which represent a fixed amount of gold and can be easily bought or sold through a brokerage or retirement account. Consider these options for a secure and convenient investment.

How long has Advantage Gold been in business?

Advantage Gold has been in business since 2014, making it a relatively new organization, but one that benefits from the founders’ extensive experience in investment.

What is a gold IRA?

A Gold IRA is a type of Individual Retirement Account that enables investors to hold physical gold, silver, platinum, and palladium instead of traditional assets like cash, stocks, and bonds. This can provide a diversified and potentially more stable investment portfolio.