Advantage Gold vs Orion Metal Exchange

In the quest to secure your retirement with precious metals, the decision between Advantage Gold vs Orion Metal Exchange is pivotal. This article strips away the excess and hones in on what matters most: fees, products, customer service, and user testimonials. Here, we provide a concise, no-frills comparison to illuminate the strengths and weaknesses of each provider, helping you choose your gold IRA custodian with clarity.

Key Takeaways

Company Overview: Advantage Gold

Established in 2014, Advantage Gold has quickly risen to prominence as one of the best gold IRA companies based in Los Angeles. Specializing in gold IRA accounts, they’ve charted a course focused on customer satisfaction and transparent pricing. But they’re more than just a precious metals company. They’re educators, helping their customers navigate the complex waters of retirement investment options.

Their main offering revolves around gold IRA accounts. This enables customers to steer their precious metal investments in line with tax regulations similar to traditional IRAs. It’s this focus on customer education and transparency that makes them a prominent player in the precious metals industry.

Pros of Advantage Gold

Beyond merely providing guidance, Advantage Gold equips its customers with an extensive array of educational resources. With a treasure trove of:

Customers can understand the benefits of investing in gold and silver, including physical gold like gold bars. It’s like having a seasoned sailor guiding you through uncharted waters.

But the real treasure in Advantage Gold’s chest is their customer service and buyback program. Their top-notch support helps customers sail smoothly through their physical precious metal investments. They offer a wide range of gold and silver products, surpassing many companies focused on direct sales, including Augusta Precious Metals. With their buyback program, investors can sell their assets back at market rates, increasing their liquidity and making Advantage Gold a dependable precious metals company.

Cons of Advantage Gold

However, every voyage isn’t smooth sailing. Advantage Gold’s lack of pricing transparency can result in stormy waters for customers trying to understand the full costs of their services.

While their BCA grade of AA signifies a high level of trustworthiness and reliability, it does not match an AAA rating. Additionally, their limitations on platinum and palladium for self-directed IRAs could limit the diversity and investment options available to investors. These are factors potential investors should weigh before embarking on their journey with Advantage Gold.

Company Overview: Orion Metal Exchange

gold, feingold, laptop wallpaper

In the other corner of our ring stands Orion Metal Exchange, another heavyweight in the gold IRA industry. Founded by Jacob Blalock, Orion Metal Exchange offers a distinct approach to precious metals investments, much like other companies such as the Oxford Gold Group.

Orion Metal Exchange isn’t a one-trick pony. They focus on a range of precious metals, including:

This diverse portfolio offers investors a variety of options. They’re also known for their transparent and fair pricing in the market, which echoes their commitment to customer satisfaction.

Pros of Orion Metal Exchange

One of Orion Metal Exchange’s shining stars is its transparent pricing. They charge an annual fee ranging from $150 to $225 for their IRA accounts, along with a $175 annual fee for storage and insurance expenses for most accounts. This clarity in pricing is like a lighthouse guiding investors in a foggy market.

Orion Metal Exchange also offers their customers the wheel by allowing them to select their own custodian and depository for their self-directed precious metal IRA. This gives investors greater control over their investment decisions. Their Trustpilot rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars, based on 138 reviews, further attests to the quality of their products and service.

Cons of Orion Metal Exchange

However, even Orion Metal Exchange has its share of rough waters. Their minimum purchase requirement of $10,000 might deter individuals with limited capital for investment.

Moreover, their lack of fee transparency can create some turbulence. They charge an annual storage fee that can affect the overall investment returns, and their charges may be comparatively high in relation to industry standards. Customers may also experience intermittent delivery delays, which can be a concern for investors.

Fees and Pricing Comparison

Having examined both Advantage Gold and Orion Metal Exchange, we can now delve into the comparison of their fees and pricing structures. It’s like comparing the costs of two different ships before setting sail on the high seas of investment.

Both companies impose a variety of fees, including set-up costs, storage fees, and custodial fees. Advantage Gold charges a one-time set-up fee of $50 and annual custodian fees ranging from $50 to $100. On the other hand, Orion Metal Exchange applies a flat fee of $175 per year for storage and insurance.

Advantage Gold Fees

Advantage Gold sets a one-time setup fee of $50 per account. But that’s not the end of the charges. Once the account is up and running, an annual maintenance fee kicks in, varying from $150 to $250 from the second year onwards. This is akin to the maintenance costs of a ship that increase after its maiden voyage.

Moreover, storing your precious metals with Advantage Gold isn’t free either. These charges include:

These additional costs can add up, much like the hidden costs of maintaining a ship.

Orion Metal Exchange Fees

Conversely, Orion Metal Exchange levies a series of charges for their services. These include setup, maintenance, and storage fees for their gold IRA accounts. Much like the costs of sailing a ship, these fees are essential for smooth operations.

Their annual maintenance fees vary from $150 to $225, depending on the customer’s account balance. They also charge a storage fee of $175 per year for most gold IRAs, which covers insurance. Depending on the storage location of the precious metals, this fee may range from $75 to $100.

Investment Products and Services

gold, coins, bullions

Comparing two vessels would be incomplete without considering what they carry. In the case of Advantage Gold and Orion Metal Exchange, it’s their investment products and services. Both companies offer a wide range of precious metals for investment, but there are some differences in their offerings.

Advantage Gold, a gold IRA company and competitor to Birch Gold Group, offers a self-directed precious metal IRAs backed by a range of IRS-approved gold coins, bars, and other precious metal products. They also offer a diverse selection of gold coins for investment purposes.

Orion Metal Exchange, on the other hand, offers a variety of investment products such as gold, silver, platinum, and palladium.

Advantage Gold Products and Services

Advantage Gold offers a treasure chest of precious metals for investment. This includes gold, silver, platinum, and palladium. It’s like boarding a ship laden with a variety of treasures.

But they don’t just offer a hoard of precious metals. They also specialize in providing services for IRA accounts, converting IRAs, or eligible 401(K)s into gold or other precious metals IRAs. They even have a specialized team to guide new investors through the initial investment process. With Advantage Gold, you’re not just investing; you’re embarking on an educational journey.

Orion Metal Exchange Products and Services

Similarly, Orion Metal Exchange presents a broad selection of physical precious metals for investment purposes. These include:

It’s like stepping onto a ship with a diverse cargo of treasures.

Their gold investment products range from various coins and bars. They also offer a variety of silver coins and bars to meet their investors’ needs. For those looking to invest in platinum and palladium, Orion Metal Exchange offers options for investments in these metals as well. With Orion Metal Exchange, you’re bound to find a treasure that suits your investment needs.

Storage and Custodian Options

When you have a treasure, you need a secure place to store it. That’s where storage and custodian options come into play. Both Advantage Gold and Orion Metal Exchange provide storage and custodial options that require your gold to be held in third-party custody to qualify for tax advantages.

Advantage Gold assists in acquiring precious metals for placement within a custodial account and storage at an IRS-approved depository. Orion Metal Exchange, on the other hand, offers various custodian options and third-party storage facilities to ensure investment security and compliance with IRS regulations.

Advantage Gold Storage and Custodians

Advantage Gold guarantees secure storage for your precious metals in certified external depositories like Brinks, located in Los Angeles or Salt Lake City. It’s like storing your treasure in a secure fortress.

These depositories, like Brinks, provide secure logistics and security solutions for gold bullion and other precious metals. Moreover, Advantage Gold also provides insurance for the stored precious metals as part of their storage solutions. It’s like having a team of expert sailors guarding your treasure chest.

Orion Metal Exchange Storage and Custodians

To safeguard their clients’ investments, Orion Metal Exchange provides a range of storage solutions, including secure vault storage and home storage. They also provide options tailored for gold IRA accounts. It’s like choosing between different safe harbors for your treasure ship.

They also provide a wide range of reputable precious metal IRA custodians and depositories nationwide. Their in-house IRA department helps clients in selecting the most suitable custodian based on their specific requirements. It’s like having an experienced captain guiding you to the best harbor.

Customer Support and Education

support, letters, scrabble

Navigating the high seas of investment isn’t easy. That’s why Advantage Gold and Orion Metal Exchange both place a high emphasis on customer support and education. They provide a range of educational resources designed to inform and empower investors.

Advantage Gold offers education on the price of gold and the advantages of tangible assets over paper assets. They aim to help their customers understand the significance and potential of gold investment. Orion Metal Exchange, on the other hand, offers a wide range of educational materials on their website to facilitate customer education.

Advantage Gold Customer Support and Education

Advantage Gold provides a comprehensive selection of educational resources, including:

These resources are like a compass and map combined, guiding investors through their investment journey.

In addition to their educational resources, Advantage Gold provides personalized account executive assistance tailored for new investors. This ensures that they receive the necessary guidance and support to navigate the initial investment process. It’s like having a seasoned sailor guiding you through uncharted waters.

Orion Metal Exchange Customer Support and Education

Likewise, Orion Metal Exchange furnishes substantial support for its customers. They can be reached via phone during service hours or via email, providing their customers with a lifeline of support when they need it.

In addition to their excellent customer support, Orion Metal Exchange offers a wide range of educational materials on their website. These resources include data charts and guidance on the processes of purchasing and selling gold and silver. It’s like having a seasoned sailor guiding you through uncharted waters.

Real Customer Reviews and Ratings

Having delved into both Advantage Gold and Orion Metal Exchange, it’s time to hear from their customers. After all, who better to tell us about the voyage than the sailors themselves? Let’s dive into the real customer reviews and ratings of both companies.

Having earned the ‘Best of TrustLink’ title for three consecutive years, Advantage Gold also boasts a solid 4.9-star rating on TrustLink, based on 488 reviews.

Conversely, Orion Metal Exchange claims a commendable 5-star average rating on Trustpilot, coupled with a flawless 5-star rating based on 52 reviews on the Better Business Bureau website.

Advantage Gold Reviews and Ratings

Advantage Gold’s impressive streak of ‘Best of TrustLink’ titles and strong TrustLink rating attests to their dedication to customer satisfaction. It’s like a ship that has won numerous races, proving its worth time and again.

However, not all reviews have been smooth sailing. While Advantage Gold has received predominantly favorable feedback, there are a few negative reviews indicating that it may not be the optimal choice for gold investments and IRAs for all investors. It’s a reminder that even the best ships can face rough seas.

Orion Metal Exchange Reviews and Ratings

Orion Metal Exchange boasts an impressive 5-star average rating on Trustpilot and a perfect 5-star rating on the Better Business Bureau website. The positive feedback frequently emphasizes:

It’s like a ship that’s consistently received rave reviews from its passengers.

However, even Orion Metal Exchange isn’t immune to occasional criticism. While they have not received any negative reviews, some customers have requested more frequent updates on gold or silver commodity spot pricing. It’s like a ship that’s sailing smoothly, but could use a few tweaks to make the voyage even better.


Our voyage through the high seas of gold IRA investments has been a rewarding one. We have explored two of the industry’s heavyweights – Advantage Gold and Orion Metal Exchange. Both companies have their strengths and weaknesses, and it’s important to consider these factors before setting sail on your investment journey.

Whether you choose Advantage Gold for its robust educational resources and buyback program or Orion Metal Exchange for its transparent pricing and diverse precious metals, remember that the right choice depends on your individual needs and financial goals. So hoist your sails, set your course, and embark on your journey towards a secure financial future.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Advantage gold legit?

Yes, Advantage Gold is a legit company, with an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau and positive customer reviews.

What is the number one gold investment company?

The number one gold investment company is Augusta Precious Metals, rated as the Editors Choice for the best Gold IRA Rollover.

How much does Orion Metal Exchange charge?

Orion Metal Exchange charges an annual fee between $150 and $225 for their IRA accounts, varying based on the investment amount and storage choice. This fee is competitive and comparable to other precious metals IRAs.

What is the downside of a gold IRA?

The downside of a gold IRA is that it lacks interest or dividends, has limited growth potential, and may have service fees that need careful consideration before investing.

What are the primary services provided by Advantage Gold?

The primary services provided by Advantage Gold are gold IRA accounts, which allow customers to manage their precious metal investments within the framework of traditional IRA tax regulations.