Expert Maine Gold Silver Review: Your Trusted Guide to Shopping in South Portland

Are you considering Maine Gold & Silver for your jewelry and precious metal needs? Our Maine Gold Silver review delivers a no-fluff, critical examination of what sets this South Portland retailer apart. Assessing the quality of service, the integrity of transactions, and the selection of products on offer, this article equips you with the knowledge to decide if Maine Gold & Silver lives up to its longstanding reputation.

Key Takeaways

Understanding Maine Gold & Silver

Maine Gold & Silver jewelry store exterior

Born out of the passion for collecting coins, Maine Gold & Silver has been a beacon for jewelry enthusiasts since it was established in 1959. Today, the South Portland-based jewelry store offers an extensive array of services, including:

The store’s half-century-long journey, marked by professionalism and dedication, has solidified its status as a trusted name in the jewelry trade.

The essence of Maine Gold & Silver is rooted in its dedication to providing an all-encompassing jewelry experience. Whether you’re looking to invest in silver coins, sell scrap gold, or find the perfect gemstone for a loved one, Maine Gold & Silver’s skilled jewelers are ready to assist. Their approach combines years of experience with a passion for jewelry, ensuring that each customer’s needs are met with expertise and personal attention in the realm of silver maine gold.

The Heart of South Portland’s Jewelry Scene

Tracing its lineage over 60 years, Maine Gold & Silver has evolved beyond being merely a business. It’s a central figure in South Portland’s community, serving generations of customers and enriching the local jewelry scene. As the only store location in the area, Maine Gold & Silver has carved out a unique niche, offering a blend of quality, knowledge, and service that sets it apart.

The store’s commitment to quality extends beyond its products. Whether you’re seeking a quick jewelry repair or in-depth jewelry appraisal, Maine Gold & Silver’s skilled team is always ready to help. With a knack for making the complex world of jewelry accessible, they ensure that every customer leaves with a smile, a piece of jewelry they love, and, often, a little more knowledge about the fascinating world of gemstones and precious metals.

Services That Shine: Appraisal to Repair

Maine Gold & Silver offers a suite of services tailored to accommodate the varied requirements of its clientele. These services include:

Every service is carried out with meticulous attention to detail and a genuine passion for the craft.

Customers often praise the store’s jewelry repair services, highlighting the skillful and prompt service provided by the team. This commitment to customer service extends even further, with the company often offering complimentary repairs for items with significant sentimental value. It’s these thoughtful touches that truly make Maine Gold & Silver shine.

In-Depth Analysis of Customer Experiences

Customers form the lifeblood of any business, and Maine Gold & Silver cherishes them like family. This approach has fostered a high rate of repeat customers, pointing to strong overall customer satisfaction. Online reviews echo this sentiment, with the majority of customers expressing positive experiences with the store.

Despite the overwhelmingly positive reviews, no business is immune to criticism. A few customers have voiced disappointment with the trade-in values offered for their jewelry pieces. While such feedback is valuable, it’s clear that the team at Maine Gold & Silver takes it in stride, using it as a springboard to further improve their services and deliver an unmatched customer experience, as evidenced by their silver reviews.

Celebrated Service: What Customers Love

As one shops at Maine Gold & Silver, the emphasis is invariably on the customer experience. Customers frequently mention the following:

It’s not just the service that customers love, though. Maine Gold & Silver’s pricing is often praised for its reasonableness, particularly for services like ring sizing, which are done in-house. By delivering exceptional service at fair prices, Maine Gold & Silver ensures that quality jewelry and expert guidance are accessible to all.

Areas for Improvement: Constructive Criticisms

Even though Maine Gold & Silver basks in a plethora of commendations, it is equally crucial to scrutinize avenues for enhancement. Some customers have reported negative experiences with customer service, such as perceived lack of responsiveness and occasional negative interactions with management. These instances, though rare, highlight opportunities for further refinement in customer relations.

Despite these challenges, Maine Gold & Silver’s commitment to customer satisfaction remains unquestionable. The company typically responds quickly to customer feedback, demonstrating a willingness to learn and improve. This proactive approach to criticism underpins Maine Gold & Silver’s ethos of continuous improvement and customer-first service.

The Selection Spectrum: From Rare Coins to Sparkling Diamonds

Assortment of rare coins at Maine Gold & Silver

In addition to its outstanding service, Maine Gold & Silver is recognized for its vast assortment of collectibles. From rare coins to gold and silver coins, the store offers a treasure trove for collectors and investors alike. But the offerings don’t stop there. Stepping into Maine Gold & Silver, you’re greeted by a dazzling array of diamonds, engagement rings, wedding bands, designer jewelry, fine jewelry, gemstones, and an impressive selection of antique, vintage, and estate jewelry.

Whether you’re a seasoned collector or a first-time buyer, Maine Gold & Silver has something to suit your taste and budget. Each piece is carefully selected for its quality and value, ensuring that customers can shop with confidence. With its wide range and expert guidance, Maine Gold & Silver offers a shopping experience that is as diverse as it is satisfying.

Numismatic Niche: A Treasure Trove for Collectors

For numismatics enthusiasts, Maine Gold & Silver is a dream come true. The store hosts a segment aptly named Norman W. Pullen Rare Coins, catering specifically to coin collectors. From rare coin appraisal to coin grading, Maine Gold & Silver offers expert services to meet the intricate demands of coin collectors.

As an authorized submission center for leading coin grading services including PCGS, NGC, and ANACS, Maine Gold & Silver is a trusted name in the numismatics community. Whether you’re looking to buy or sell collectible coins or invest in gold and silver bullion, Maine Gold & Silver provides a broad spectrum of options, making it a one-stop-shop for collectors. In addition to their expertise, they have a strong partnership with Paramount International Coin Corp, ensuring the highest quality of service.

Dazzling Displays: Exploring Their Jewelry Offerings

Elegant diamond engagement rings at Maine Gold & Silver

The jewelry selection at Maine Gold & Silver includes:

The store offers an extensive range that caters to a variety of tastes and styles. Each piece is meticulously selected for its quality, resulting in high customer satisfaction.

The estate jewelry selection at Maine Gold & Silver is particularly renowned, acclaimed as the finest in New England. Customers often describe the store as a ‘hidden gem,’ offering unique jewelry pieces, competitive pricing, and a large, diverse selection. Whether you’re in search of a timeless classic or a statement piece, Maine Gold & Silver promises a fulfilling shopping experience.

Pricing and Value: Is It Worth Your Investment?

In matters of pricing and value, Maine Gold & Silver aspires for transparency and fairness. To learn about fees and pricing for the store’s services, customers are encouraged to contact the company directly, ensuring personalized and accurate information. It’s worth noting that the store only accepts cash as a form of payment for bullion, a policy that may affect some investors.

Ensuring that customers feel confident in their purchases is a priority for Maine Gold & Silver. By maintaining open lines of communication and providing clear pricing information, the store strives to create a shopping environment that values transparency and mutual trust.

Evaluating Fair Price Commitments

Maine Gold & Silver’s commitment to fair pricing is a cornerstone of its business philosophy. The store understands that investing in jewelry or collectibles is a significant decision, and strives to provide customers with a fair, market-driven pricing structure that ensures value for money.

This commitment extends to all aspects of the business, from the sale of collectible coins and bullion to the pricing of repair and appraisal services. By adhering to a fair pricing policy, Maine Gold & Silver builds trust with its customers, ensuring they can shop with confidence knowing they are receiving a good deal.

Behind the Scenes: The Expertise at Maine Gold & Silver

Expert gemologist examining gemstones at Maine Gold & Silver

The distinguishing factor for Maine Gold & Silver against its competitors lies in the immense expertise operating behind the scenes. The team comprises professionals with decades of experience in the jewelry and numismatics industry, each bringing their unique skills to the table. From President Norman Pullen, a lifelong coin collector, to Vice President John Colby, a veteran of the American Numismatic Association, the leadership team at Maine Gold & Silver is steeped in knowledge and passion.

But it’s not just about leadership. Graduate gemologist Allisyn Gray brings her specialized knowledge to the team, contributing to the store’s reputation for competitive prices and extensive knowledge in the jewelry market. This combined expertise ensures that each customer benefits from personalized attention and professional guidance, enhancing the overall shopping experience.

A Legacy of Trust: Company Leadership

At the helm of Maine Gold & Silver are Norman Pullen and John Colby, whose leadership has been instrumental in sustaining the business and fostering a culture of integrity and responsibility. Their vast experience, combined with a shared vision for excellence, has guided Maine Gold & Silver towards growth and success.

Under their stewardship, Maine Gold & Silver has evolved from a modest coin business to a full-service jewelry store, renowned for its quality products, exceptional services, and unwavering commitment to customer satisfaction. This legacy of trust, built over decades, continues to drive the company forward, cementing its place as a leader in the jewelry trade.

Shopping Experience: Setting Expectations for New Customers

Maine Gold & Silver is devoted to crafting a delightful shopping journey for its patrons. The store’s updated operating hours, from Tuesday through Saturday, are designed to support staff well-being and enhance customer service quality. The store opens at 10:00 a.m. each operating day, offering a convenient time for customers to start their shopping experience.

Whether you’re a seasoned collector or a first-time buyer, Maine Gold & Silver’s team is dedicated to helping you find the perfect piece. They take the time to understand your needs and preferences, guiding you through the selection process and ensuring you leave with a purchase you’ll cherish.

First-Time Buyer’s Guide

First-time buyers at Maine Gold & Silver can expect:

The staff at Maine Gold & Silver is trained to make the buying experience stress-free and informative for first-time customers. They explain the factors influencing item pricing, such as market rates and item rarity, ensuring customers understand the value of their purchase. With various payment options available, Maine Gold & Silver makes it easy for first-time buyers to complete their purchases, setting the stage for a long-term relationship built on transparency and trust.

Transparency and Security: Website and Business Practices

Transparency and security form the bedrock of Maine Gold & Silver’s online presence and business operations. The company’s privacy policy outlines the collection and use of personal information, ensuring users’ rights to access, rectify, or erase their personal data. Cookies and similar technologies are utilized for navigation, remembering user preferences, and serving targeted ads, with policies in place to guide these practices.

In line with Federal Trade Commission guidelines and anti-money laundering legislation, Maine Gold & Silver upholds transparency in transactions, with a certified team trained in compliance and supervisory procedures. The company also employs security measures to protect user information online, acknowledging the importance of safeguarding customer data in today’s digital age.

Community Engagement: Maine Gold & Silver’s Local Impact

The influence of Maine Gold & Silver extends beyond the confines of its store. The company is deeply engaged with the local community, demonstrated by initiatives like the Feed the Hungry Fund. In partnership with Good Shepherd Food Bank, this initiative raised $12,325, providing 49,000 meals to Mainers facing hunger.

The Feed the Hungry Fund involves taking donations of metals that cannot be sold for cash, refining them, and donating the proceeds to fight hunger. The refining company partnered with Maine Gold & Silver waives all processing fees and covers shipping costs for the metals donated to the Fund. This initiative is a testament to Maine Gold & Silver’s commitment to giving back to the community and creating a positive impact where it matters most.


From its humble beginnings to its current status as a trusted name in South Portland’s jewelry scene, Maine Gold & Silver has demonstrated a consistent commitment to quality, service, and community engagement. With a wide selection of collectibles and jewelry, expert services, fair pricing, and a dedicated team, the store offers a shopping experience that is as rewarding as it is unique. Whether you’re a collector, an investor, or someone looking for the perfect gift, Maine Gold & Silver invites you to discover the exceptional value and personal touch that sets it apart.

Are you prepared to broaden your financial investment portfolio?

The investment in gold and various other rare-earth elements can assist diversify your investing portfolio. Because gold has little or no link with equity or bonds, it lowers the risk for you in total amount. You can put your money right into gold with specialized gold IRA companies.

Frequently Asked Questions

What services does Maine Gold & Silver offer?

Maine Gold & Silver offers buying and selling of coins and jewelry, as well as jewelry repair, custom design work, and professional appraisals.

What collectibles are available at Maine Gold & Silver?

Maine Gold & Silver offers a wide variety of collectible items, including rare coins and gold and silver coins. Consider visiting them to explore their collection.

How does Maine Gold & Silver ensure fair pricing?

Maine Gold & Silver ensures fair pricing by providing a market-driven pricing structure and encouraging customers to directly inquire about fees and pricing for their services.

What initiatives does Maine Gold & Silver engage in for community engagement?

Maine Gold & Silver engages in community engagement initiatives such as the Feed the Hungry Fund, which raised $12,325 for Good Shepherd Food Bank, providing 49,000 meals to Mainers facing hunger. These initiatives demonstrate their commitment to supporting the local community.

What can first-time buyers expect at Maine Gold & Silver?

First-time buyers at Maine Gold & Silver can expect a thorough explanation of the purchase process and access to educational materials about different types of metals and gemstones. This will help them make an informed decision.