Liberty Coin Review: An Honest Take on Value and Trustworthiness

Are you considering a purchase from Liberty Coin and curious about their reputation? In this liberty coin review, we’ll directly tackle the trustworthiness and value for money that Liberty Coin offers, informed by customer ratings and firsthand accounts. We understand that transparency in pricing, coin authenticity, and customer service are at the forefront of any coin collector or investor’s mind. Dive in to uncover the strengths and weaknesses of dealing with one of Michigan’s largest coin dealers, and decide for yourself if they meet your numismatic needs.

Key Takeaways

Unveiling Liberty Coin’s Reputation

A variety of liberty coins and rare coins

Liberty Coin, known for their reliable and consistent service, enjoys a high level of customer satisfaction. Their trustworthiness in the coin dealer industry is reflected by liberty coin reviews:

However, their reputation is not untouched by blemish; some customers express concerns about their customer service, leading to a moderate average Trustpilot rating of 3 out of 5. This varied customer sentiment highlights the need for potential clients to be aware of both the positive and negative aspects of dealing with Liberty Coin.

Customer Endorsements and Criticisms

Liberty Coin’s ‘Average’ Trustpilot rating reflects a diverse range of customer experiences. While some customers endorse the company for its fast and friendly service, others report issues with handling large orders and discrepancies between offered prices and delivery. This mixed bag of reviews underscores the reality that while many customers have had positive experiences with Liberty Coin, others have been left dissatisfied.

Although all the negative reviews exist, they do not solely represent the overall customer experience, and one must consider the positive reviews as well.

Examining the Fair Price Promise

Liberty Coin’s commitment to fair pricing is evident in their close adherence to spot metal pricing. Customers trading gold jewelry and rings have reported positive experiences, noting transparent processes and receiving higher payments than expected. Furthermore, novice customers have found Liberty Coin’s valuations align with their researched prices, reinforcing trust in the company’s fair pricing.

Fair pricing significantly contributes to Liberty Coin’s strong reputation, offering a very fair price to customers.

Navigating Liberty Coin’s Website and Services

A person browsing Liberty Coin's website

Liberty Coin’s website is a treasure trove for collectors and investors alike. It offers a wide range of products, including coins, bullion, and numismatic items. The company offers a comprehensive range of services and products that cater to a diverse customer base.

The intuitive website design enhances the customer experience by simplifying the exploration and purchase of items.

User Experience Online

The transaction process on Liberty Coin’s website is straightforward, and customers appreciate its ease of navigation. The website offers the following features:

These features aid customers in making informed decisions and enhance their overall shopping experience.

Customers can readily access their order history and account details for post-purchase requirements, which adds to the overall user experience.

Service Spectrum

Beyond buying and selling, Liberty Coin offers a variety of services to cater to the needs of its customers. These include:

Their expertise extends beyond numismatics to areas such as foreign currency exchange and rare paper money, showcasing their wide-ranging knowledge in collecting and investing services, despite all their nonsense that might surround these fields.

Liberty Coin’s Market Presence

A vintage photo of Liberty Coin's storefront

Liberty Coin has carved out a strong presence in the market since its establishment in 1971. It has grown to become Michigan’s largest dealer in rare coins and precious metals, serving a broad customer base across 49 states. Their base in the Frandor Shopping Center in Lansing, Michigan, has been a constant presence since 1975, underlining their commitment to their locality.

Company Legacy

With over 50 years of service, Liberty Coin is a veteran in the numismatic industry. Their reputation for honesty, integrity, and fair dealing has been cultivated over the decades, and they continue to uphold these values in their business operations today. Their constant presence in Lansing, Michigan, has solidified their legacy and standing in the community.

Industry Authority

A customer who asked Liberty Coin about their team learned that it consists of numismatic experts with a collective experience of over 250 years, specializing in various currencies including gold coin and silver coins. Their significant industry influence is demonstrated through active memberships in coin-related organizations, including four members in the prestigious Professional Numismatic Guild.

As an authorized dealer for leading grading services like PCGS and NGC, Liberty Coin offers trusted coin and currency authentication and grading services.

Customer Support Analysis

Customer support experiences with Liberty Coin vary. Some customers have praised the fast and friendly service, while others have reported issues with customer service and order fulfillment.

The spectrum of eBay’s customer service experiences includes smooth transactions with fast shipping and some dissatisfaction with order handling.

Responsiveness to Inquiries

While some customers have reported efficient service, others have described challenges in communication. Instances of difficulty in reaching Liberty Coin by phone have been reported, including unavailability during expected business hours and unprofessional interactions with customer service agents.

However, some first-time customers have mentioned quick responses to their messages, indicating that responsiveness can vary.

Resolution of Complaints

Resolution of complaints is an area that has garnered mixed reviews. Some customers have reported being treated poorly, with instances of dismissive attitudes, rude interactions, and unresponsiveness to complaints.

In response to such issues, Liberty Coin suggests that customers may:

Pricing and Value Transparency

Pricing and value transparency at Liberty Coin are affected by several factors. These include a $50,000 limit for orders paid by paper check, sales tax collection based on state regulations, and fluctuations in spot market prices. While these factors can impact the overall customer experience, they are part of Liberty Coin’s commitment to providing clear and transparent pricing information to its customers.

Pricing Policies

Liberty Coin’s pricing policies include a $50,000 limit on payments by paper check and sales tax collection based on state regulations. However, some customers have raised concerns that Liberty Coin’s pricing may not always align with current spot market prices, leading to uncertainty in the overall cost of transactions.

Value for Money

When it comes to value for money, customers have generally expressed satisfaction with Liberty Coin. They note that premiums are often more competitive compared to larger dealers, making transactions with Liberty Coin a good investment. However, some customers have reported issues with calculating sales tax on eBay purchases, which can impact the overall value for money.

Customer Transaction Experiences

Customer transaction experiences at Liberty Coin are a mix of positive and negative experiences. While many customers have reported perfect transactions characterized by fast shipping and excellent service, others have encountered challenges with the handling of orders.

These mixed experiences underscore the need to comprehend the potential variability in customer experiences before initiating a transaction.

Fulfilling Orders

Secure packaging for shipping rare coins

When it comes to fulfilling orders, Liberty Coin charges customers’ credit cards only within 24 hours prior to the item(s) being shipped, ensuring billing corresponds closely with the delivery process. Several customers have reported satisfactory experiences with Liberty Coin’s quick shipping, with items being dispatched promptly and arriving as expected.

However, there have been instances where customers encountered issues with large orders, resulting in dissatisfaction due to lost work days and the need to return shipments because of poor quality.

Handling Discrepancies

Liberty Coin’s handling of discrepancies involves a 14-day return policy for numismatic items. To process a return, a customer must contact Liberty Coin Service and send back the item insured and in its original packaging. However, customers have reported issues with the quality of shipped items, including scratches and marks, which can impact overall satisfaction.

Ethical Practices and Business Conduct

Given the potential for scams and exploitation in the coin industry, ethical practices become paramount. Therefore, businesses like Liberty Coin must maintain the highest ethical standards and business conduct.

Unfortunately, high-pressure rare coin marketing is a common scam within the coin dealing industry, making senior citizens particularly vulnerable.

Integrity in Transactions

Just like any other business, Liberty Coin also considers transactional integrity as a fundamental aspect. However, customers have lodged complaints about unethical seller behavior, delayed delivery coins, and dissatisfaction with the offers made, calling into question the integrity of some transactions.

In one instance, a senior gentleman lost a significant portion of his investment due to so much obvious overhead, raising concerns about questionable practices.

Dealing with Dissatisfaction

Addressing customer dissatisfaction is key to customer service. Liberty Coin’s approach towards dissatisfied customers has been critically evaluated, with some customers cautioning others about their negative experiences. In response to such issues, Liberty Coin advises customers wishing to return a product to follow the seller’s return instructions and contact the seller if there is an issue with the return policy being honored.

Investing with Confidence: Liberty Coin’s Track Record

Liberty Coin’s track record speaks volumes about the company’s credibility. The company maintains an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau, indicating strong trust and satisfaction among customers.

Feedback from eBay, where Liberty Coin sells its products, is overwhelmingly positive, further affirming the company’s reputation.

Investment Security

Security is of utmost importance in investments, and Liberty Coin meets this expectation. Customer testimonies highlight successful trading experiences and significant withdrawals, reinforcing the company’s image as a secure and trustworthy investment destination.

Claims of achieving complete financial stability through dealings with Liberty Coin contribute to the narrative of security and reliable investment management offered by the company.

Collector Satisfaction

High-resolution images of collectible coins

Liberty Coin values collector satisfaction highly in their service offering. The company caters to collectors by providing a diverse selection of rare and collectible coins. Furthermore, collectors can confidently make purchases due to Liberty Coin’s thorough product descriptions and high-resolution images, allowing for informed decisions regarding coin quality and authenticity.


In conclusion, Liberty Coin offers a comprehensive range of services for collectors and investors, backed by a strong market presence and an established reputation in the numismatic industry. However, it’s important to understand that customer experiences vary, with some praising the company’s fast and friendly service, while others raise concerns over customer service and order fulfillment.

Are you prepared to broaden your financial investment port mix?

The investment in gold and various other rare-earth elements can assist diversify your investing profile. Due to the fact that gold has little or no connection with equity or bonds, it lowers the threat for you in overall. You can put your cash right into gold through specialized gold IRA companies.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Liberty coins worth anything?

Yes, Liberty coins can be worth anywhere from $10 to thousands of dollars, depending on factors such as condition, mint year, and coin type.

Are gold liberty coins real?

Yes, gold Liberty coins are real and are produced by the Mint with modern designs of Liberty and Eagle on the reverse. These coins are made with 24-karat gold and are also available as silver medals.

What karat is a Liberty coin?

The Liberty coin is typically made of 90% gold, which is equivalent to 21.6 karats.

How to sell Liberty coins?

You can easily sell your Liberty coins and other precious metals by filling out a form or calling 800-747-5860 to request a quote. Simply list the specific coins you have for faster service.

What is Liberty Coin’s reputation in the coin dealer industry?

Liberty Coin is generally recognized for reliable and consistent service, but some customers have expressed dissatisfaction with their customer service. Keep this in mind when making a decision.