J.J Teaparty Review: Your Comprehensive Guide to Coin Collecting Satisfaction

If you’re scouring the web for an honest j.j teaparty review, look no further. With a critical eye, we examine this veteran coin dealer’s selection, customer service, and pricing. Our impartial critique will arm you with the facts you need to decide if J.J. Teaparty is the trustworthy partner for your numismatic journey.

Key Takeaways

Exploring J.J. Teaparty: A Brief Overview

J.J. Teaparty storefront with a signboard

Established in 1957, jj teaparty is a reputable numismatic coin dealer. This company is among the oldest rare coin firms and has consistently upheld its quality standards over the years. The company initially based in Boston and now residing in Virginia, specializes in rare collector’s coins, including NGC and pcgs certified coins.

This dedicated focus on quality and rarity has earned J.J. Teaparty a respected position among precious metals retailers in the USA. The company is a lifetime member of the American Numismatic Association, a testament to its commitment to the numismatic fraternity.

The Team Behind J.J. Teaparty

Portrait of Scott D. Sparks, owner and president of J.J. Teaparty

An experienced team is the driving force behind J.J. Teaparty’s successful operation. Scott D. Sparks, with his comprehensive knowledge of the wholesale coin market, serves as the owner and president, steering the company to success. His leadership has undoubtedly been pivotal in maintaining the high standards of the company.

Supporting him is Melissa L. Sparks, the Comptroller, who manages the website, oversees customer communications, and assists with orders and payments. The strategic direction provided by Gail Watson, the Interim Director of Sales and Marketing, has fortified J.J. Teaparty’s position in the market. The team is further bolstered by highly respected numismatists who set pricing standards within the industry.

Delving into J.J. Teaparty’s Coin Collection

Assortment of rare collector's coins

Both collectors and investors are drawn to the diverse array of rare collector’s coins offered by J.J. Teaparty, including valuable collectible coins such as Morgan Dollars, silver coins, trade dollars, half dimes, and half cents. We’ll explore their collection in depth, along with the certification processes that guarantee authenticity and quality.

PCGS Certified Coins

Global recognition for coin authentication and grading comes in the form of the PCGS certification. This standard is invariably upheld by J.J. Teaparty, providing assurance to collectors worldwide.

The coins graded by PCGS at J.J. Teaparty are guaranteed for their grading accuracy and authenticity, offering significant value to buyers. This rigorous grading process ensures every PCGS certified coin you purchase from J.J. Teaparty aligns with your value expectations.

NGC Certified Coins

Much like the PCGS certification, the NGC certification is a critical aspect for numismatic coins. It provides an independent assessment of a coin’s condition and authenticity, thereby enhancing buyer confidence.

Every coin in J.J. Teaparty’s collection undergoes the NGC certification process, ensuring its quality. Their range of NGC certified coins includes Morgan Dollars with varying attributes, catering to collectors with different interests.

Gold IRA Investments with J.J. Teaparty

A wide variety of IRA-eligible products, including gold bullion and coins such as American Eagle, Australian Kangaroo/Nugget, Austrian Philharmonic, and others, are offered by J.J. Teaparty. However, do bear in mind that the company does not facilitate Gold IRA investments.

Investing in a Gold IRA with J.J. Teaparty involves various fees, including:

These fees are typically higher compared to traditional IRAs. Additionally, when you choose to withdraw from your Gold IRA, you have the option to receive the physical metals or have them sold for cash. However, it’s important to note that these transactions are subject to taxes and may incur penalties similar to traditional IRA distributions.

J.J. Teaparty’s Reputation: Ratings and Customer Feedback

Customer reviewing coins at J.J. Teaparty

With an A+ rating on the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and a 3.5 out of 5 stars rating on Yelp based on 5 customer reviews, J.J. Teaparty has cultivated a positive reputation in the numismatic community of Easton MA 02356. Furthermore, there have been no complaints registered against the company on the BBB in the last three years.

Customers have consistently expressed satisfaction with their purchases from J.J. Teaparty, both in terms of quality and pricing. The company is commended for offering good material at competitive prices, setting a high benchmark for other coin dealers. Though some customers felt the service could appear uninterested or curt, positive reviews praise the company’s honest practices, including paying close to the spot price for coins.

Comparing J.J. Teaparty to Other Coin Dealers

In comparison to other coin dealers, J.J. Teaparty distinguishes itself as a great coin shop with:

Unlike price guides that may be out of touch, J.J. Teaparty’s coin prices potentially include a premium reflecting their expertise and guaranteed authenticity.

J.J. Teaparty holds a commendable standing alongside other respected dealers such as Gerry Fortin Rare Coins, David Kahn Rare Coins, and Brian Greer Rare Coins. The authenticity of their coins is a testament to their commitment to quality, despite customers suggesting improvements could be made to the presentation, such as coin photography.

Services Offered by J.J. Teaparty

Offering a range of appraisal services for estates, trusts, and personal coin collections, J.J. Teaparty handles items such as coins, paper money, and gold and silver bullion. The company also provides in-home appraisal visits for qualifying collections, catering to customers who require on-site evaluation of their holdings.

Customers wishing to sell their coins can utilize J.J. Teaparty’s outright sale option, where they can transact directly with the company and receive immediate payment. J.J. Teaparty is recognized for assisting collectors in building their collections and is regarded as a reputable source for collectors seeking expertise and education in numismatics.

Pricing and Fees at J.J. Teaparty

J.J. Teaparty places a high value on transparency, a key aspect of customer satisfaction, by listing the selling prices of their products directly on their website. The pricing of products is competitive, with precious metals often having a small markup over spot price, which can be as low as 2% or 3%.

Furthermore, unavailable products are not displayed on the website, ensuring that the listed products have accurate and current pricing. This transparency and honesty in pricing further enhance customer trust in J.J. Teaparty.

Final Verdict: Is J.J. Teaparty the Right Choice for You?

As a legitimate coin dealer, J.J. Teaparty boasts a strong reputation and offers a diverse selection of quality coins. However, it’s pivotal to remember that J.J. Teaparty does not facilitate investments in Gold IRAs.

No recommendations for Gold IRA custodians or related services are provided by the company. Therefore, if you’re seeking Gold IRA investments, it would be wise to consult top gold IRA companies for appropriate services.


In conclusion, J.J. Teaparty stands as a reputable numismatic coin dealer with a diverse selection of rare collector’s coins. Their emphasis on authenticity, quality, and competitive pricing, backed by a stellar rating and positive customer feedback, sets them apart in the industry. While J.J. Teaparty may not cater to Gold IRA investments, their transparency and commitment to customer satisfaction make them an excellent choice for coin collectors and precious metal investors alike.

Frequently Asked Questions

What types of coins does J.J. Teaparty specialize in?

J.J. Teaparty specializes in rare collector’s coins including NGC and PCGS-certified coins such as Morgan Dollars, silver coins, and trade dollars.

Does J.J. Teaparty facilitate investments in Gold IRAs?

No, J.J. Teaparty does not facilitate investments in Gold IRAs.

How is the reputation of J.J. Teaparty in the market?

J.J. Teaparty’s reputation in the market is positive, as evidenced by their A+ rating on the Better Business Bureau and 3.5 out of 5 stars rating on Yelp.

What services does J.J. Teaparty offer?

J.J. Teaparty offers appraisal services for estates, trusts, and personal coin collections, in-home appraisal visits, and assistance in building collections. These include appraisals for estates, trusts, and personal coin collections, in-home visits, and collection-building assistance.

How does J.J. Teaparty ensure transparency in pricing?

J.J. Teaparty ensures transparency in pricing by listing selling prices directly on their website and offering competitive prices with small markups over spot price. This helps ensure that only available products with accurate and current pricing are displayed.